I don't think playing MAT in CF and hitting him 8th is going to kill this team. The defense is pretty good, the occasional power is nice. It is very close to being like carrying Danny Espinosa, except in CF rather than SS. I think it was HattoriHanzo who clamored for Turner at SS and a real CF like Taylor down the stretch last year, rather than the Espinosa / Turner combo. If Taylor and Turner field well, fine.
I'd love to see Taylor develop into a guy who keeps his Ks <25%, draws a few walks, and keeps the power. I doubt it happens and I think something like a Cain / Herrera deal should happen to backfill for Eaton this year and to give us a better bullpen for this year and next. Short of that, Taylor or Goodwin is what we go with.