All signs point to Scherzer staying in Detroit. As much as it pains me to say it, good for him. I am with Slate on this one, he is a beast of a pitcher and I don't think he is going to turn into a pumpkin going forward.
For a real issue though, I'm not convinced in a back end of the rotation consisting of Taylor Jordan, Tanner Roark, Nate Karns or Chris Young. I know everyone bashed on me about Samardzija earlier this year, but he has one more year of control than Scherzer, is probably at best a number 2, and could be had for less prospect pieces. I know Chicago tends to overvalue him, but there might be a trade there. I think Rendon is safe to stay, and a combo of Storen, A.J. Cole and Purke would be able to get Samardzija.