My friend just a bought the lime green colored fiesta from the commercials. That's a sexy car. They liked it better than the Mazda 2. The Fit is a nice car even though I'm not crazy about Honda, and that new Fiat is just really intriguing. I imagine the Fiat will be cheaper because its a 2 door. I'd try the Mazda 2 and the Nissan Versa as well.
www.edmunds.com will give you free all the pricing info from Consumer Reports that you have to pay 25 dollars on top of your membership before. Both sites have incredibly good reviews. Get the internet price from a lot of dealers, new cars are not selling as well as used cars, so they really want to sell. What decided me on the Mazda 5 was a 95/100 rating from Consumer Reports, a price that was the same as a 5 year old used CR-V for a brand new car, the driving experience, and the sliding doors.
Good luck, I LOVE having a brand new car. Everything works!