I'm definitely pleased with this deal for the next four to five years. But something I find interesting, reading the comments on the Fangraphs article... It looks like 90%+ are extremely negative on the entirety of the deal. Overpaying, too many years, and most interestingly something I haven't seen in this thread, that we signed Werth to a huge contract when we have little to no chance of competing. Most of the comments over there, nearly 80 thus far, seem to think that since we won't have the pieces together until 2012, and it'll be until 2013 until they hit their stride, that the deal makes no sense.
My point is, am I the only one that finds it surprising the non-DC reaction to this is overwhelmingly, nearly universally, negative? You really have to look to find any positive opinions on this deal outside of Nats fans. I certainly don't get it, I'm thrilled and think it makes perfect sense for the next five seasons. After that, no.