Rosenthal seems to be looking good, last I checked. Might turn out better than Kimbrel.
But that's irrelevant. Doolittle, Rosenthal can't pitch every game. We get into stretches of 15 games straight... players are gonna need rest. It's about depth. Depth when guys get fatigued and when they get aches.
Doo has seen the DL each of the last few seasons. Can this team in this division afford to give up games?
We win this division last season if we won 9 more games. And look at the guys we were missing for 30 games at least each. Stras, Zimm, Doo, Murph, Howie.
There will be points in the season were we Starters don't go more than 5. When the back end of the bullpen are required for a bunch of innings in a short period games.
Do you really want to see Solis throwing in the 9th because Doo and Rosenthal need a day of rest minimum? Last year (iirc) we had 14 total Blown Saves. Doo accounted for only 1. So 13 when Doo didn't go for the save.
If we stay healthy and don't lose core players for months at a time... we win this division.
But Doo sees the DL every season so far. And Rosenthal is just coming off of TJ.