Jose Reyes or bust.
In a weak pitching market, guys like Edwin Jackson and CJ Wilson are going to be horribly overpaid. I can't imagine CC comes here, even if he does opt out. So signing a decent pitcher to a bloated contract isn't wise long term. Especially with arms on the horizon. Milone, Peacock, Detwiler and Wang are fine for two spots next season. Solis could even be in the mix. If Meyers impresses, him as well.
If none of those work out, the 2013 crop of FA pitchers is much better. Greinke, Marcum, Haren, Hamels, Cain, etc are all FA's. Sign one of them if we still have two open slots at the back end of the rotation. Id rather pay huge money to someone that deserves it, in the year that we should be contending(still think a lot needs to be figured out in 2012).
Id entertain trading for someone, especially if we signed Reyes. Desmond and Storen is a decent start for a good starter. With our minor league system, including two prospects should get us a legit 2/3 starter.