I don't know. I think Collins is a guy that relies more on his head and less on his arm - because he has to. Campbell could certainly get there (and further), but sometimes being a very gifted athlete can delay a player's mental progression - having always trusted your arm, its harder to trust that a really good scheme trumps it.
I thought the acquisition of
Brunell was a huge mistake, since no GM in the NFL wanted him when Jacksonville benched him. (The Redskins front office admitted that they would have grabbed
Kerry Collins instead, if they knew that the Giants were going to release him, after they made the trade with San Diego to get Eli Manning. Keep that in mind if
Jim Fassel is hired.) I don't think that Campbell benefited from playing with the practice squad for so long. He fumbles a lot, doesn't read defenses well at times, and overlooks open receivers downfield at times. He needed to replace Brunell much sooner, and got stale on the bench.
They need to get a big receiver who is 6'4" or taller, like Campbell's teammate from Auburn, whom they hired late in the season.
Team with big WR's made it to the playoffs. STOP getting more shrimpy receivers!!Gibbs admitted that he took over the play calling for most of the 2007 season, when the Redskins got in the red zone. That explains why the teams couldn't finish drives. Remember the exact same running play, called six times with the penalty, in the loss to the Giants at FedEx? Gibbs kept calling it, the Giants kept stopping it. I agree that Gibbs finally backed off late in the season, and gave Saunders full control. Keep him.
The Skins had one of the worst defenses in the NFL in 2006, and I think that may be giving Snyder pause about hiring Gregg Williams as head coach.