MAT would have looked better with the curly 'W'. Better ballplayer than Robles and plays all three OF positions. Hits for power, like Gallo but with 100 point better average.
In 2023, Gallo had a higher OPS in 2023. .741 over .720. If you are just concerned about average, then we are talking .220 vs .177 last year. Last 3 season, Taylor has had OPSs of .653, .670, and .720. Gallo has had .621 (in NYY), .671, and .741. The same hitters, basically. I like Taylor's D, but if you are down on the Gallo signing, then the biggest thing for the 3 year older guy is he's $1 million cheaper.