I am impressed with Atlanta's team this season, and I believe they can be a solid team over the rest of the season. But in looking at their lineup this season, I am struck by how much good fortune they have had up till now -- especially when compared to Washington.
Of the eight players in Atlanta's starting lineup for their first game this year, seven have now played in at least 50 games. The one who hasn't was their catcher, who got beat out for the job by Suzuki. Suzuki has now played in 53 games. So their basic starting lineup has been pretty much intact throughout the season. Three of their starters -- Freeman, Markakis and Flaherty -- are having career-best years in terms of OPS+. Suzuki actually had a higher one last year, but his OPS+ for this year is 33 points higher than his career average. (Markakis's is 30 pts higher).
Meanwhile in Washington ...
Four of the players in our starting-day lineup -- Eaton, Zimmerman, Wieters and Kendrick (who was himself a replcement for Murphy) -- have played 40 (Kendrick) or fewer games. Of the other four Rendon is now 11 pts above his career average for OPS+ and Taylor is four pts above. But Turner is 12 pts below and Harper 17.
Maybe our players are just more injury-prone. Maybe Markakis and Suzuki have suddenly figured it out in their mid-30s. Maybe Harper will defy baseball history and become a .200 hitter after winning an MVP before he turned 25. But I say the odds are better that The Nats' lineup performs better for the rest of the season than it has up to now, and the Braves' performs worse. It's a crazy game, with a lot of twists and turns that are impossible to predict, but that's what it looks like to me.