Our oldest daughter graduated there in 2009...
My lasting recollection was when the then President, Nichol, told the incoming students "You were all in the top 10% of your class when you graduated High School...when you graduate W&M, 90% of you won't be." I though that was a good grounding speech...though he himself got grounded not long after following some stupid moves that pissed off the donors.
We were there for the Queen's 50th anniversary of her first visit...that was quite something...
I guess the big question for you guys is did your daughters do the Triathlon?
(1) Jump the wall of the Governor's Palace in Colonial Williamsburg and/or run through the maze of the Governor's Palace, (2) Swim (sometimes naked) in the Crim Dell, (3) streak across the Sunken Garden
Daughter claims she did with her roommate but not completely naked.
She was on the judicial council and got to meet Sondra Day O'Connor. I think that was the highlight. Or maybe Jon Stewart visit.