Yes. Only one of a handful of schools who have never made the NCAA tourney. Yea seems weird. Not a step up. Earl is a Princeton guy. Will try not to hold that against him.
William and Mary, Citadel, and West Point are the only teams in existence at the start of the NCAA tournament system who have never made it.
W&M competes in the CAA. Their football program has gotten better in recent years, hopefully this is a good sign for the basketball program as well.