Guzman! absolutely not. No range. Espinosa: would have been, perhaps, except he wasn't really a shortstop. (Only one season as regular shortstop.)
Espinosa: 13 DRS in 1,826 innings at shortstop
Turner: 9 in 4500
Best season at shortstop
2008 Guzeman: 12 DRS
2016 Espinosa: 11 DRS
2018 Turner: 8 DRS
2021 Turner: 0 DRS; -1 Outs Against Average