How old are the voters?
You conveniently forgot about WAR, the most important stat.
A corner OF cannot produce the same WAR as a SS or CF. Defense for those positions is not valued as much. Someone like Tatis is not a good SS but will generate higher WAR than Soto or Harper because of his position. You are also adding in pitchers who will not get MVP votes (deGrom may have if not injured). Harper will finish in the top 5 in the MVP vote. Soto will get votes also. BTW, Harper is 7th in offensive WAR.
