I think Lindor is very good and his offense contributes to that. But it’s disingenuous to compare the numbers of a guy in his prime to a retired player.
I'm generally comfortable comparing era-adjusted offensive stats like OPS+ at the same age. Also, Lindor would not be Lindor without elite defense. I don't think Jeter, Garciaparra, or Tejada were regarded as elite defenders. Vizquel, on the other hand, never was in Lindor's class of hitter.
Also, to be fair, I'm comparing that signing to what 2 HoF-level guys produced and 2 other guys who were on that track at that point in their careers. I think I saw that that is the 3rd biggest contract to date? For that money, I think you should be getting a likely hall of famer. Lindor needs to keep up his fielding and stick at SS for 6 or so years to be a HoF candidate, I think. Could happen, but there's a lot of risk that's not discounted.