So JAWS has Zimmerman 39th among 3rd basemen, they don't list him in the 1st base rankings. He's just behind Deacon White (38th) who made the HOF. Everyone ranked 13th or higher, except for Greg Nettles, made the hall. His JAWS score, if transferred to the 1st base list, puts him just ahead of Freddie Freeman in 46th place. There too, 13th and higher have all made the Hall except for Palmeiro, Cabrera, and Pujols.
Last night's homer tied Zimmerman with Ted Kluszewski for 183rd all-time, he's two behind Paul O'Neill for 182nd. If he manages to hit another 10 this year, he'll move into 164th place.