I agree.
Where is this clear and convincing evidence that Strasburg is miles ahead of Scherzer? Scherzer was better in ERA, FIP, K/9 and finished ahead in Cy Young voting. I think Strasburg is great and may be better than Scherzer, but I just don't see how it's so clear that one is better. If you think Strasburg should get the nod because he won the WS MVP, that's totally reasonable, but you can easily justify either decision.