I'm glad neither of you have a HoF vote.
I think the case for Schilling in the HoF is pretty strong.
http://m.mlb.com/news/article/160682426/hall-of-fame-case-for-curt-schilling/ notes that since the mound was lowered in 1968:
Strikeout-to-walk ratio: 1st (4.38)
Strikeouts per 9 innings: 4th (8.6)
WHIP: 4th (1.137)
Walks per 9 innings: 6th (1.96)
WAA: 6th (54.1)
ERA+: 7th (127)
Strikeouts: 9th (3,116)
WAR: 10th (80.7)
Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP): 11th (3.23)
The article notes "From 2001-04, at the advanced ages of 34-37, he led all pitchers in WAR, with an average of 7.8. Schilling also was first in strikeout-to-walk ratio, second in strikeouts, third in innings and FIP and fourth in ERA+. For good measure, he won seven postseason games and two World Series rings."
He's arguably among the best playoff pitchers in history: "In 19 career postseason starts, he went 11-2 with a 2.23 ERA, including a 2.06 ERA over seven Fall Classic outings. Schilling was the MVP of the 1993 National League Championship Series for the Phillies, threw a shutout in that year's World Series against Toronto, and he set a single-postseason record for strikeouts (56) for the 2001 D-backs. That year, he produced a 1.12 ERA, and Arizona won five of his six outings, which included three complete games and a shutout."
By any reasonable analysis, Schilling is a HoF-worthy pitcher.
He's just not one when you look at his personality.