Just looking at the top 10, I find it odd that the 3 I might kick about is Mantle at 9, Clemens at 6, and Williams at 3 or 4. I am a Williams fan, but I can't see him ahead of Dimaggio given the defensive difference (or indifference, in Williams case). Williams is top 10, but not just behind Bonds, Mays, and Ruth. Clemens should not be ahead of Walter Johnson among righties. He's probably better than Maddux due to longevity, but hey, I would not put him ahead of Pedro
. Mantle, I don't know.