I kind of like the idea of either Bush. Putting aside that they are
Y , Poppy was a torpedo bomber in WWII, so it is a nod to that generation, and played baseball. There's the great picture of him and Babe Ruth when Joe Wood arranged a visit to school. Poppy is vigorous, too, ran while at the White House. It'd be cool to honor him now, especially after his recovery.
As
, the fact that he owned the second Senators after the move has its pluses and minuses, I suppose. He also kept
when he sold the franchise to Hicks, so there is even more of a linkage. He stays fit, and is personable. He threw out the first ball at the opening of the Park, so that is another tie to the club.
If it is about a President who has the stature of the Rushmores, then the only easy answer would be FDR, but I can't see having one racer on a scooter. While there are terrific wheel chair marathoners, a sprint is not appropriate.
Ike is probably the most accomplished inside and outside the White House (Hoover and Carter were more accomplished outside than inside).