Wrapped up my little roadtrip, flying home to Arlington in a few hours. Quick summary/snap judgment of some of the places I stopped:
Coopers Rock State Park: no-brainer stop if you are ever driving to Morgantown. Just 3 miles from the I-68 exit is an amazing scenic overlook of a river valley. I saw two Bald Eagles here.
Morgantown, WV: extremely hilly college town where there can be a significant change of elevation between places a block away, including on the main college campus area. The PRT is even more incredible than I dreamed. Lots of food options.
Wheeling, WV: Sad! Desolate, empty town full of beautiful abandoned buildings, including stunning skyscrapers that are now entirely boarded up. Like Allentown, PA but even more run down. Given its prime position on I-70 and its proximity to stunning natural beauty, it should have more of a tourist industry than it does. A downtown casino does not seem to have turned things around here.
Moundsville, WV: Located 20 mins south of Wheeling, a much more alive West Virginia northern panhandle town. The star attractions here are an ancient Indian mound from the Adena culture (over 2,00 years old) that is huge, and the old West Virginia state prison that is gorgeous and that the town has clearly monetized to the greatest extent possible as a tourist attraction and community center. They hold flea markets there, they have a haunted house there (that I didn't go to because it was completely sold out), and they have something called "Mock Prison Riot" there that sounds way more fun than the mock trail I did in law school.
New Vrindaban, WV: Community built by the Hare Krishnas in the 1970's. They have a big gold and marble palace that was built as a house for the founder of the Hare Krishna movement. They also have a temple dedicated to Krishna, an on-site hotel for pilgrims, a beautiful lake with swans, and peacocks that roam the entire property. Very reasonably priced gift shop. Most of the visitors are immigrants from India who come as pilgrims - they live in places like Toronto, New Jersey, or Pittsburgh and this is way closer than India. The tour guides are all white converts from the US/UK. Our tour guide (a formerly Jewish guy from New York) repeatedly quoted from the Baghavad Gita in Sanskrit and was disappointed that none of the Indian-American tour guests were able to complete the quotes.
Marion, OH: the home town of President Warren G. Harding, whose house here can still be toured. Warren G. Harding died in office in 1923 of heart failure and his house was immediately given to local historical preservationists, so everything in the house is original to Warren G. Many other Presidential houses had people who lived there after the President but before it became a tourist attraction who threw out the President's stuff, etc., but not here. Marion was also the popcorn manufacturing capital of the USA at one point and the local historical society museum has a ton of old popcorn machines. Our tour guide at the popcorn museum used to live in Arlington, VA not far from where I do in the 1960's and worked at the Navy Annex. We talked about Arlington, VA at length. He hadn't heard of any of the businesses I mentioned and I hadn't heard of any of the businesses he mentioned.
Ada, OH: This small town of 5,000 people has stayed vibrant because of a small college (The Ohio Northern University, ONU). Wilson has its football factory here: all footballs used in the NFL and in NCAA games are manufactured here. I was there on Monday, the only day they do not offer tours of the factory, but I saw people stitching up footballs from the window.
Fort Wayne, IN: Built where the Maumee and St. Marys rivers meet to form the St. Joseph River, this city has a decent skyline comparable to Grand Rapids. Downtown looks nice and has parks but is full of scary-looking vagrants.