Yes, he raked. I believe he was top 10 in OPS+ last year. He wasn't as protected as you might think last year, he carried that lineup while everyone else was on the DL.
He certainly did not carry the team.
His high KO ratio - he simply doesnt have the power numbers to justify the number of K's he has. His doubles were up last year, but RBIs, HR's were both down from the previous year.
The first half of the season he was not very good - he is a good hitter on a good team, try and make him a focal point player and he is not going to carry a lineup offensively. Nothing in his career (if you watched him play on a daily basis) should have made any scout think he could.
I didn't say anything about his contract. I asked what scouts should have noticed last year that would tell of his 2011 woes.