I've always liked Pelfrey. I think Niese and Dickey are trash though.
You think Niese, a 23 year old lefty who had 5 solid starts last year, is trash? His WHIP is a bit high (1.43) mostly due to a BABIP that is about .030 over league average. That's the biggest negative I can find. Do you have even the slightest bit of supporting evidence for that or is it right up there with the Jason Bay has been horrible nonsense?