You have been on his case for awhile. Just thought I would throw come basic stats at you. Also factor in the size of their contracts.
2023 AB'S HR's BB K BA OPS
GALLO 282 21 48 142 .177 .741
ROSARIO 478 21 34 122 .255 .755
I'd rather go with Rosario if I had to choose between either.
the same number of homers in 200 fewer ABs. near same OPS. Gallo is the better defender and at the same position and plays another.