Take away the 'roid-fueled MVP year this year and he's just OK. No better than Morse. Is it worth taking on a guy with a reputation like Melky's for that kind of production? There are plenty of other players who would be just as good. Shane Victorino could do the same thing and play very good defense in CF, for example. Angel Pagan is another guy.
Victorino wants a multi yer deal and had a down year. Angel pagan is well, angel pagan
