All I'm saying is Suzuki isn't the catcher people think he is. And I like how you clipped only '08-'11. You forgot 2007 and 2012. Ramos will be a good player, and I'm not happy the Nats traded a good young catcher in Frietas to the A's for a guy who is mediocre at best. Given some more time, Frietas could have blossomed into a great young catcher.
Nobody is calling him the savior. I don't know where you think we're all expecting him to be a HOF catcher.
Flores was the current starter and wasn't getting the job done. So he's going back to a reserve role. We all know Ramos is our catcher for the next few years, nobody is taking that from him.
Why would I post Suzuki's numbers from his rookie when he only played in 68 games (with a plus WAR)?
And I already stated Suzuki has struggled this year offensively. But if history is an indicator, he's usually a pretty decent bat with some pop.
You had this to say: "And I can safely make the assumption Suzuki won't be successful."
I think a lot of us disagree with that.
