You guys realize one bad start doesn't take away the validity of his mediocre season? I mean that as a positive. He's been average and wouldn't be the worst 4 or 5 of all time.
He has to be a 5 and no better if you hope to contend. But then again this team is not looking to contend. They're only looking to extend the date of contention and save money. The Lerners Are Chazzer.