After a scientific survey with sample size of 6, Brooklyn's Chocolate Stoudt was the winner of Young's Chocolate Stoudt by a 4 - 2 margin.
Actually, it seemed to depend on whether one likes a creamy beer (Young's) vs a beer with a little bite (Brooklyn). But I like them both and I never would have tried Young's without the good advice of posters. So thank you for the suggestions.
I think I still prefer the Young's. If I want to get completely sloshed, Brooklyn will do nicely, but if I am just in the mood to chill out, I'll grab a Young's.
Plus over $11 for a six pack of Brooklyn? Damn, that can hurt the wallet at times.