First of all, I've seen Bergmann get rocked numerous times. I have also seen Hill be consistently above average. There is no contest and using Sutton to make your point will not change that. Like sportsfan said, I too am certain Sutton would tell you that Hill is the better of the 2.
That's flat out wrong. Hill has not been "consistent". He was great before getting hurt. But he has not been "consistent" since then. And while Berg was not great by any stretch of the imagination at the beginning of the season, he pulled it together, did great and got hurt. Came back too soon and wasn't ready so didn't do well at all. Went out hurt again and has been just as "consistent" as Hill was before he was injured. So this consistent talk is pure BS and you know i.