Author Topic: Should we trade Harper?  (Read 2291 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Expos

  • Posts: 448
Re: Should we trade Harper?
« Topic Start: October 26, 2017, 04:56:49 PM »
You will never get the value for Harper that you will get from him playing on the team. If this team plans on contending next year it makes zero sense to trade him, unless some of the folks proposing trades on here are MLB GM's hiding their identity.

Harper is a worst case a 5 win player. Best case he is a 10+ win player.  There is no way you're even going to get even one year of that production back in trade. Much less multiple years.

Just for comparison 2015 Bryce Harper is the equivalent of Carlos Correa AND Paul Goldschmidt. 2017 Harper even with injury is the equivalent of one of them. Do you think Nats are getting anything close to that back in a trade.

(I know I am leaving out 2016, but I think can that was a fluke and he was hurt.)

So? Have him for 1 year then lose him for nothing?

If he signs a big extension this year then great. But then we risk losing Rendon.

I'd rather take a package of young players under control AND a signed Rendon than Harper.