Yes. Mike Trout is a typical power hitter. Turner plays the way Charles Leerhsen describes Ty Cobb, in the biography, "A Terrible Beauty". Cobb always looked for a way to keep the other team off balance. If baseball has a rhythm, Cobb changed the rhythm. Like time changes in jazz.
Turner would be better at 2nd, short, and 3rd, and likely better at first.
Trout is probably a better catcher.
The Trout team would be stronger offensively, but the Turner team might make it up on defence.
Also, imagine how many bags Turner would rip if the catcher was an outfielder.