You cant draft for immediate need in baseball. Even college bats are a few years away so I think you go BPA.
I think Fedde fit that at that point. He was ranked top 10 before the injury. He has great command of his fastball and is a very good athlete. The down time after surgery and the rehab process should allow him to get stronger overall. Maybe add a couple pounds to his frame, but more importantly, add a little more stamina/durability. The athleticism should allow him to get back to form once hes back on the bump. I dont think hes an ace but think theres definite 2/3 potential.
Pitching is always valued more. As in impact on the club and as value in trades. I dont have a problem going another arm in the first.
Definitely need some bats and some youth in the lower levels of the minors though.