i like carroll, i would rather have a hard working SS who hustles and tries to make plays. Guzman to me seems lazy. anyone remember that play against the astros, where guzman waited before throwing?
dumb play, almost allowed a base hit. he just got the ball and waited. carroll isnt a gold-glover, but at least he tries. id rather watch that.
also, carroll can do the fundamentals of bunting and moving the runners over very well. he is a smart player who hustles on the basepaths and knows where the ball is at all times.