I think we need to keep ALR because there's no way Moore can duplicate his defense. Just in the last week, I've seen ALR save Desi an error and Zim two, and arguably a couple of Rendon's just through amazing defense. You can't quantify the value of that as it never shows up on the stat sheet (if it did it would only be a bad thing). That said, I still have faith in ALR to hit adequately. He's just streaky as hell and when he's in a bad streak it's going to be a bit ugly. The thought of losing his glove scares me considering the wildness of Zimmerman throwing to first, and Desi's ability to make stellar plays leaving him some margin for error on the throw knowing ALR is a black hole for anything close.