It's not really a crime, it's the system. To get on the All Star team he would have had to be voted by the fans, which wasn't going to happen. He was not going to be named to the team by the manager when we already had five players, and that seems reasonable to me. I suppose Maddon could have omitted Strasburg and named Rendon instead, but then we'd be nagging instead about Strasburg. Perhaps Rendon deserved it more than Zimmernan (I said "perhaps") but Maddon didn't have the option to omit Zimmerman because he was voted in as a starter. And if Zimmernan had not been an All Star, well, that would indeed have been crime.