This is a great, great, great... freaking awesome steal of a deal. Meyer for three years of Span? Two set in stone for $11mil plus a third team option for only $9mil? That's just smart baseball.
That said, I'm not a huge fan of it. Only because it guarantees LaRoche or Morse goes. While I doubt Rizzo makes the deal if they expect LaRoche resigns, and it indicates talks had broken down... I'm not 100% on that only because it is such a steal, Rizzo would have been nuts to turn it down. I really, really wanted both guys back and the OF to remain as is with Harper in CF. If it ain't broke, etc. Bottom line, the lineup we had was stellar and meshed. On paper Span sure isn't a downgrade, but clubhouse chemistry and leadership wise, I think Morse and LaRoche both played a big part, contributed to the success dramatically off field and outside of stats.
Great deal, no complaints, and at the very least this isn't a net loss. Short of having both LaRoche and Morse back, this was probably the absolute best case scenario and best deal we could have made. But I still wish 2013 saw our 2012 roster with added playoff experience and Strasburg 100% to make the run for the whole shebang. With the situation as is, they'd better let LaRoche go. I'd be quite unhappy, disappointed and pessimistic if we lose Morse via trade over LaRoche. I think Morse will contribute far more, on and off field, to the 2013 team returning to October and advancing further. Morse is just great, bringing a spark and intense energy, motivating and leading the team and loved by the fans. LaRoche might be more of a sure bet stats wise, offensively and at 1B, over Morse, but like I said, some players have value beyond their stat sheet and Morse is undoubtedly one of them.