He put up solid numbers early in 2011 (ERA under 4 with very respectable peripherals), and then got called up and shat the bed. After he got sent down, he started suddenly giving up runs at AAA, but his start to 2011 wasn't too far off from this season's.
Unless someone's watched him pitch and can verify that he's no longer throwing a flat, 89 mph fastball, they should never let him sniff the Majors.
