What the shaking finger or rant doesn't work? Of those I like the next to last one with the hands on hips etc on it.
The finger shaking one is more of an "oh, no you didn't" or "watch yourself" type of smiley, and the other one is more nagging than anything. The shaking head smiley could be used when something ridiculous is said here or happens during a game.
Example: If Dukes strikes out 3 times in a game and has a chance to redeem himself w/ the bases loaded and 2 outs, and then he K's again, I'd wanna show how I felt w/ a shaking head smiley.