Chapman and Bailey as of now are better than Leake. Leake started off incredibly strong but as of the past couple months he has come back to earth. One theory is the league has adjusted to him but also he seems to have lost a little bite off his fastball. The opinion around Reds country is he doesn't have the endurance yet to last an entire MLB season.
Sure, that's what any fanbase would have. And, hopefully that's all it is. But on the outside looking in, if you take a look at the track record of Baker, it is reasonable to question that there could be more than just fatigue. You can see that, right?