Actually, I would only want one of those...
Realistically i would want 4 of them. Claudio Vargas just pitched a gem last night. He struck out 11, and struck out 3 straight with the bases loaded. The only one i would be skeptical about is Tony, though i would take him over Jerome and Chico any day. I'm curious to know which 1 of the 5 listed you would want. I'm guessing it would be Ortiz? Since he's 3-0 with a 2.00 era.