He's great when you compare him to Dunn.
First basemen are supposed to be able to dig out throws in the dirt, and most can. Dunn isn't a first baseman, but he's one of our only options when NJ has a day off.
With all due respect, ronny, I watched Nick on a daily basis whey he was with the Yankees; he is a great defensive 1B.
You're right that Dunn is one of our only options to give NJ a day off, but it doesn't mean he's a good option. He just happens to be better than Belliard.