I'm interested in getting one of these books more for the scouting reports than the fantasy value. How are the scouting reports in Sickels? I've heard the ones in BA are pretty thorough and detailed. I have no idea about BP's book.
By the BP book, I just meant the annual Baseball Prospectus, the telelphone-book-sized thing that profiles each team, has some general analysis, and a top 100. In each organization, they recap last year's roster plus a certain number of prospects. If a guy moves on to an new organization, then his profile will be with the prior year's team. Thus, we get to see a recap of Bally's season in the Nats section, while the analysis no doubt will discuss the impact of the move on his projections for 2012.