I agree about Milledge, and Manny does seem inconsistent. I think Dukes would be a better choice for Center. Kearns is the best defensive outfielder of the bunch, although I know defense is not much regarded around here. He's hitting very well. You wouldn't start him? I would.
But I'd have Dukes in center. I don't get Manny's blind spot on this. Maybe he's trade bait?
This from JMad:
The same could be said for Kearns. Other than a streaky Spring, what exactly has Kearns done to earn the spot?
