The question is, does ALR repeat this season or decline quite a bit. Wasn't this pretty much LaRoche's career year? Plus he's on the wrong side of 30.
He'll probably decline a bit, put up his more typical year:
.270/.340/.470 25 HR and +Defense
He's been remarkably consistent when healthy, not sure if he'll hold up for three more years but I could live with giving him the third year.