Not sure how you lay this one on Davey.
Well, he had a completely rested bullpen and went back to Clippard in the 8th when he had so much trouble getting out of the 7th. In reality, he could have done matchups for each batter, just because he had his entire bullpen except for Gorzelanny.
And Clippard had so much trouble getting Kotsay out on Tuesday. He had Clippard figured out but Davey stayed with Clippard.