Sens, you would have loved it I bet. It was called the "Rustic Tavern", which was an understatement. Had one table inside that seated 14 people. You stood in the doorway until there was a seat available, no preferences, you just joined the lunchroom community there. Guy ran it was named Jesse, he was an older black guy whose specialty was pies, but it was down home cooking at its best. Cheap, too. I would get the open face turkey sandwich with fries, and gravy all over it, and a piece of chocolate chip pie for desert. Unbelievable.
I went by a couple of years ago looking for it, but it's long gone, though the building is still there. Adjacent to the pedestrian mall downtown.