0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Votes versus statistics, I guess.
I think they should just let the fans vote for one player on each team.
That is an interesting idea, how would the process work in that case?
Player rater?
So, which is going to take less time. This game or all the pregame stuff?
And how is Russell Martin put in over McCann?
The fact that Jason Varitek is there is a complete joke and an insult to so many other players.
The most controversial player selection was probably Jason Varitek, who was elected in the worst season of his career: .218/.300/.358. While this provides a big target, when you look at the available options, Varitek’s selection is almost understandable. Joe Mauer is the best catcher in the league. The candidates, other than Varitek, are Jorge Posada, who missed most of the first half, and Victor Martinez, who played nearly as badly as Varitek did. Other than Mauer, no AL catcher has put up a 15.0 VORP. I’m not sure selecting the adequate bounceback seasons of A.J. Pierzynski or Ivan Rodriguez would have been that much of an improvement on Varitek. I love Dioner Navarro (Bandwagon!), and he was a manager’s pick, but he’s from the great-first-half category of All-Stars. Varitek is here basically because he was the choice of a plurality of people who didn’t vote for Mauer. That’s not a ringing endorsement—it’s just something that happened.
Tell me again, why do we rise and stand at attention for God Bless America? When did this become our National Anthem 2.0? It's a great song and all, but really? Is it really equal to the Star Spangled Banner? I say no.