I'm sorry, is that a question or an answer ?
Do you think that Zimm is a top 20-30 player (in MLB) or not ?
He's certainly top 20 defensively, top 40 offensively perhaps. Just a guess, but it doesn't really affect my argument much. I think you are imposing a bias towards current major leaguers, but I am with Goldstein in principle that the fact that Strasburg, or any yet to reach MLB prospect, can certainly be rated ahead of proven major leaguers for purposes of this exercise. It's not about where they are now, but where they are headed.
