I thought this team was better balanced than the previous years, despite obvious flaws. Even with the injuries, they still showed up and battled and gave themselves a chance in each game. Not surprising that certain concerns all year ended up being their downfall.
My three keys to the game were Max keeping the ball in the park, Righty bats doing their jobs, and Dusty learning something from his previous losses - particularly about being one batter too late on the decisions and not understanding matchups. Unfortunately, they were unable to succeed on all three keys, and each ended up being the difference in their own ways. Still a bit pissed that the failure to find a CF ended up leaving us with Danny throughout the playoffs. Still confounded by roster make up decisions. Still not sure that Harper is healthy, but he still was able to do some little things that helped scrape runs across and given them chances to score runs. Still pissed that so many guys are unable to fly out with a guy on third and one out.
All in all though, despite the little failures, I though these guys showed up. This wasn't as much a choke job as just being on the wrong end of some things - that's baseball. I think Roberts managed like there was no tomorrow and Dusty never did, and that was at least part of the difference (which may be generous to Dusty.) I always had a fear that while Dusty would keep the club house happy, when it came to pushing buttons, his stupidity would end up costing them. It did. And Bob Henley's too.
One shining difference was Melancon. Still can't believe that Rizzo allowed Storen to have so many additional chances to freak over the team. Mark did his job. Trea is the future. I expect Max to be Max for more years, and the team to be in a good position for continued success. I just wish that it didn't seem like every year they missed out on that one hole they failed to plug, because of either Rizzo hubris or Lerner cheapness. Was hoping they would get through the first round just once, even if the Cubs were looming. Oh well. Next season.