I agree.

How the hell can a relative nobody like Gil Meche possibly be described as an "impact pitching talent"?

When and where exactly did he make his "impact", because I must have somehow missed it.

His ERA is usually nearer to 5.00 than it is to 4.00.

I'd love to know how the worst team in baseball spending over $50 million on such a mediocre talent is likely to get them out of the basement.