There's a reason Brad Lidge was available, and available for a rather cheap price at that. I'm not saying he has no value, but he's definitely not the dominant closer he once was. I believe that H-Rod has only had the one bad outing this season (and still hasn't given up an earned run), so I'd stick primarily with him for the time being. He's definitely more "lights out" than Lidge. Lidge would be a good 7th-inning guy.
